The great debate begins....

Charlie, Presumed Dead

By: Anne Heltzel

Genre: YA mystery

Pages: 272

Published: 2015

Read:  August

3 out of 5

The premise was good and unique, and the book held my interest, but the ending was so bad and rushed it changed my entire perception of the book. This book was chosen as a teen book club choice because one member LOVED it and another HATED it. There is a constant debate between them, so we decided to open it up for group debates. I have very mixed feelings and can see both girls’ point of view, however in the end I feel the book is just an average YA book. There is a definite twist I didn’t anticipate, which I can understand influencing the teen readers, but the book also lacks luster. My favorite aspect was that it was told by three narrators – one being Charlie, who is presumed dead, and his voice was told in second person as though you were him. Interesting choice!